How to Choose a Catcher’s Mitt: The Five Decisions That Matter
How to choose a catcher’s mitt in five decisions, in order: ball, size, leather, pocket and fit — with the size chart, the leather grades, and where each catcher lands.

From this page you can access all of our reviews of Fastpitch Softball catcher’s gear (scroll below). In this category, reviews typically cover gear for ages 12 and up.
Our top picks for each category of Fastpitch catcher’s gear are shown below. Click the image to check the price!
Top Catcher’s Helmet: Jen Schro The Very Best

Top Catcher’s Mitt: Wilson A2000 FPCM

Top Chest Protector: Jen Schro The Very Best
Top Leg Guards: All-Star Vela

How to choose a catcher’s mitt in five decisions, in order: ball, size, leather, pocket and fit — with the size chart, the leather grades, and where each catcher lands.
How to break in a catcher’s mitt the way that lasts: hand work, a ball overnight, daily catch, a mallet, and no heat — with break-in timelines for the Heart of the Hide, A2K and Pro Elite.
Steerhide, kip, Japanese-tanned, Heart of the Hide, Pro Stock — what catcher’s mitt leather names actually mean, and which leather fits your catcher.
Heart of the Hide vs Jen Schro: we compare the Rawlings 33in and Easton 34in fastpitch catchers mitts on leather, break-in, lefty fit and price.
(If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. See more.) Catchers have a lot of gear, and combined with the season’s travel demands, it’s pretty clear that having a high quality catchers bag is a must. This post reviews four different catchers bags, all top picks for specific categories that matter to…